Friday, April 29, 2011

Holden and His Problems

There are many times in the book where Holden thinks that he is a saint and all of the things that are happening to him are somebody's fault other than himself. Holden likes to view himself as perfect person however, in order to do that he must point out everyone's flaws to make himself look good and cover up all of his other mistakes that he has done in the past. He can't accept the fact that it is okay to be wrong every once in a while or to make mistakes because that is a part of growing up and being human. Because of this Holden can be very hard on himself and gets mad that he isn't as perfect as he would like to be.

In the beginning of the book Holden gets into a fight with his roommate Stradlater because he was talking down about this girl Holden likes and just being flat out disrespectful about her. Holden does the same thing and thinks so horrible things right along with it. He may not do it to that girl in particular but he does it to random people like the hooker he picked up.

Holden calls everyone around him a phony and cruel but he is the same way at times. He may not see it at times but he does it often. Holden doesn't like it when people aren't real around him but yet when he talks to his authorities He either acts like he cares and feeds them lies about his life or anything that they want to hear. He will also just be rude and brush them to the side like he is better than them even if he is younger than them. Holden treats people with disrespect but makes an attitude when they do it to him. As you read the book you find out that the more he sort of breaks down that the less he is able to handle it. However I do think that he starts to realize as time goes on that he is very hypocritical and not only hard on himself but also expects more out of others than really necessary.

Holden is a good person at heart overall but at the same time he can be very rude toward people. All people can be that way though. Everyone does judge one another and have bad days where they come across rude or disrespectful. It is about how you go about it though. You can spread roomers, go insane, fly off the wall on some random person at the store, or become isolated and try to end your life because you are having a hard time or you can keep your opinions to yourself, try to work it out with someone, or do what you can to handle things in an appropriate manner. Either way it must come from you and I believe that Holden is beginning to recognize that.

7 comments:

Gustavo said...

I know what you mean because some times I can't man up to something even if I know i'm wrong, it's a hard thing to do but when you finaly do it you relize that it's not always wrong because you learn and next time you might be right but Holdens to ignorant to see that.

nate said...

I enjoy reading your journals because they are not just superficial. You actually use your head and try to look deeper into Holden, not just dwelling on surface things. I agree that Holden's actions will have consequences, which you state. I think that he already has experienced a lot of these. I agree that Holden is beginning to recognize this concept, as you said. Good job using your head, I liked it more than most papers. For future references "roomers" is spelled "rumors" haha. Good job.

Elee said...

He really is hard on himself and it's sad to see. I've noticed as I got to the end of the book that I came to really like him. A lot of teens have the problem with being hard on themselves due to what others influence. Great paper.
Elee

Aubrie said...

Holden needs to see that he is what he hates about other people. He is just as phony as everyone he thinks is fake. He just blames everything that goes wrong on all the phony's around him, but he's the biggest phony out of all of them.

jon said...

i disagree that he is as disrespectful to women. he seems to want to have sex but he respects them when they say no and he also with Sunny after seeing how young she was and when he thought of her going in to the store to buy it their not being any one who knew why she bought it.
However i do agree with you when you said that he is a good person at heart.

Edgar :D said...

I totally forgot that he got in a fight about that one girl he used to like thanks for reminding me. well written. well thought out. kinda long but that's OK.

Shaunda said...

I really like the story cause I can see some dudes feel like there right all the time but the dude in this story got to know that it's ok to be wrong some times but we got to respect each other